The Riding Gravel Forum
Sign up Calendar Latest Topics
 
 
 


 
Poll Results
 
 What is your favorite frame material for off-pavement riding?
 Aluminum 2 5%
 Carbon 9 22%
 Steel 22 55%
 Titanium 7 17%
 Bamboo 0 0%
 View Voters
Total votes: 40   Please or sign up to vote.


Reply
  Author   Comment  
frontrangegravel

Moderator
Registered:
Posts: 429
Reply with quote  #1 
What is your favorite frame material for off-pavement riding?
0
ayjaydee

Member
Registered:
Posts: 88
Reply with quote  #2 
Steel is my favourite by far. I spent enough time working in the fields of failure analysis and materials science to ever trust carbon fiber in an activity where the risks of nicks causing stress concentration sites are so probable. As for aluminum, my teeth are already too loose.
0
frontrangegravel

Moderator
Registered:
Posts: 429
Reply with quote  #3 
I'm curious how you explain all the carbon fiber mountain bikes going through unprecedented seasons and events. I know you said that you're not into racing, but in this instance, a race like the Vapor Trail 125 doesn't eat carbon bikes alive. If that doesn't, I'm not sure what would. I know several that were fine, myself included.

In a tamer environment of riding daily on not so crazy surfaces and aggressiveness, what would be the potential of carbon blowing up?
0
ayjaydee

Member
Registered:
Posts: 88
Reply with quote  #4 
As long as the carbon doesnt get nicked in an area of high stress, all will be fine. BUT, once it does, there is little elasticity to relieve the increased stress levels caused by the stress concentration factor of the nick. Steel , as an elastic material, has a much better chance of deforming slightly to relieve these elevated stresses. Carbon fails catastrophically, steel tends to fail elastically over a longer time.
0
frontrangegravel

Moderator
Registered:
Posts: 429
Reply with quote  #5 
I'm a big fan of ti, although the cost is just tough to swallow.
0
wirider3

Member
Registered:
Posts: 20
Reply with quote  #6 
I'll take carbon if given to me, ti if I have the money, but steel fits the bill all around.
0
BobMorrisJr

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 2
Reply with quote  #7 
Carbon, carbon, carbon. Use it for road, mountain and whatever else and have had no problems.
0
Simpleton.

Member
Registered:
Posts: 40
Reply with quote  #8 
All my bikes are steel because I can't afford Ti.
0
spacelysprocket

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 2
Reply with quote  #9 
I've never owned anything but steel.
0
jwc

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 2
Reply with quote  #10 
Carbon suits me just fine
0
Garrett

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 1
Reply with quote  #11 
I've only ridden steal, Karate Monkey, if I ever buy a new frame it would be steal too.  Even for being a "mountain" bike the Monkey is pretty smooth on gravel.  
0
GRAVELBIKE

Avatar / Picture

Member
Registered:
Posts: 57
Reply with quote  #12 
All of my current bikes have steel forks/frames. I'm building up a 29er that'll see double-duty as a gravel rig, and that bike will have an aluminum frame and carbon fork.
__________________
GRAVELBIKE.com - ride everything
0
Jon Marshall

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 5
Reply with quote  #13 
I've had aluminum and titanium gravel bike frames, both with carbon forks.  I do not think there is a difference in ride quality.  In my experience, ride quality is in tire width and pressure.
0
ridemagnetic

Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered:
Posts: 161
Reply with quote  #14 
Carbon for racing, Steel for everyday, Ti for a middle age crisis, Aluminum for drinking beer out of.     
__________________
A great set of wheels will make an average frame ride better. It doesn't work the other way around.  ~ridemagnetic
0
mnswamp

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 16
Reply with quote  #15 
Poor downtrodden aluminum.  I've been riding aluminum cross bikes for years, and my primary 'grinder is an alu 7075 cheap*ass Nashbar CX frame with a Wound-up carbon fork.  The big rub on alu is always that it buzzes and has a harsher ride.  I submit that most of this can be eliminated with good wheels, tires, saddle and bar tape without giving up on weight/lateral stiffness.
That said, most of my road bikes are carbon.  and my new build is carbon all the way.  The amount of tuning that can be done to a carbon frame - if properly engineered - is better than can possibly be done with steel.  While I completely agree with the concerns about carbon frames, nicks and major damage, I think the technology has advanced to the point that a properly engineered bike has enough redundant strength to withstand most failure mechanisms.
0
dj

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 2
Reply with quote  #16 
Honestly it's hard for me to tell the difference. I've rode for a long time on all materials and I really don't know that I could tell the difference if I was blindfolded and unable to hear the cables rattling on the frame so I really don't have a favorite material. I guess I'm partial to steel since that's what I started on, but I wouldn't say it is my favorite.

d

0
GravelMN

Avatar / Picture

Starter
Registered:
Posts: 12
Reply with quote  #17 
Chrome-moly steel all the way IMHO, but then I'm primarily a recreational rider, not a racer. I've got nothing against CF and know many riders who love it. For those wanting to get into gravel on a budget, you can put together some fine gravel mutts out of cro-mo MTBs, hybrids, and touring bikes from the early 1990s.
__________________
"Those who say it can't be done should stand aside for those who are doing it."
0
Previous Topic | Next Topic
Print
Reply

Quick Navigation:

Easily create a Forum Website with Website Toolbox.